Coffee Origins that Drink their Own Crop
While most origins grow coffee to sell it abroad, Brazil, Ethiopia and Indonesia consume 30% - 40% of their coffee at home, and Brazil, the world’s largest producer, is also its second-largest consumer.
This is unusual because coffee spread across the tropics as a cash crop, grown to be exported and earn foreign currency rather than to be consumed locally. Even today, most coffee origins ship almost everything they grow, and this is, in fact, the basis for how we typically distinguish between origin and destination markets: where coffee is produced and where it is consumed.
Brazil, Ethiopia and Indonesia blur that line: their large populations and coffee-drinking traditions make them origin and destination (for their own coffees) at the same time.
[Get a clearer picture of the coffee market. Start your free trial and explore our in-depth research and analysis.]
This makes their balance sheets less transparent: in most origins, exports are a good proxy for the crop, but in these three, a third or more of the coffee is drunk at home and never shows up in export data. It also leaves less coffee for the US, Europe and Asia, where most coffee is consumed and stockpiled, so a bad crop hits exports first and can quickly tighten the stocks that importers rely on.
In this article we will look at why Brazil, Ethiopia and Indonesia are different from the rest of the origins, what the recipe for high origin consumption is, and what it means for the coffee market.
The Norm: Origins Are Net Exporters
For most producing countries, coffee is more of a valuable commodity, and less of a drink. Take Uganda and Vietnam, for example, these are among the largest origins, and yet they export 90-95% of their crops.
This goes back to how coffee spread. When coffeehouses took off in Europe in the 1600s, the colonial powers wanted to stop depending on Yemen’s port of Mocha, so they planted coffee in their colonies, from Java to the Caribbean and Brazil.
In the 1800s, newly independent countries such as Costa Rica, Colombia, Guatemala and El Salvador expanded it on purpose to earn foreign currency and strengthen the local economy. Local incomes were low and, in many places, tea or other drinks were already the daily habit. So ultimately, coffee was grown mostly to be shipped.
Brazil: Top Producer & Second-Largest Consumer
Brazil is the biggest outlier. The world’s largest producer is also its second-largest consumer, drinking more than 20m bags a year, about a third of its crop. Three things explain it: size, culture and structure.
[Make more informed coffee market decisions. Try our Premium Reports free and see what you've been missing.]
With around 213 million people, even a modest habit adds up, and that habit runs deep in Brazilian culture. If you have been to Brazil, you may have been offered a "cafézinho". It is served in homes, offices, and shops all day, and coffee with milk and cheese bread is part of the standard breakfast, so Brazilians are coffee drinkers, by culture.
The market structure helps, too. Brazilian roasters run on local beans, including the lower grades that buyers abroad don’t want, and the country also has a large soluble industry. Brazil does not ban green coffee imports, but strict plant-health rules, import tariffs and a powerful producer lobby have kept them negligible for decades.
2017 was a prime example of that: after a drought hit the robusta crop, the government approved imports of 1m bags from Vietnam, only to suspend them within days after famers protested.
Ultimately, Brazilians drink about 6 kg of green coffee per person a year, more than four times the world average of about 1.3 kg.
Brazil’s home market is also one of the main reasons analysts disagree on the size of its crop. Domestic consumption is hard to measure, and estimates vary with each source’s methodology, so they rarely agree. Since many analysts work out the crop from exports, stock changes and home use, a gap of a couple of million bags in consumption becomes a gap of the same size in the crop.
The split between arabica and robusta adds another layer of complexity. Brazilian blends use a lot of conilon (robusta), and local roasters shift toward it when arabica gets expensive, so the same total consumption can leave very different amounts of each for export.
Together, these explain why estimates for Brazilian crops typically vary by a few million bags every year, depending on the source.
Ethiopia: Where Coffee Is a Ritual
Ethiopia keeps about 41% of its coffee at home, and the main reason is a combination of size and culture.
[Want to stay on top of coffee supply and demand? Sign up for a free trial of our Silver Plan Premium Coffee Research.]
With around 130m people, the large population plays a big role in coffee consumption. Ethiopians drink about 2.3 kg of green coffee per person a year, almost double the origin's average of about 1.3 kg.
However, population alone does not explain it. Take Uganda, for example, Africa’s second-largest producer: it has around 50m people (also a big population) but drinks less than 5% of its coffee, about 0.4 kg per person, yearly. So, per person, Ethiopians drink about six times as much coffee as Ugandans, because in Uganda coffee was developed as an export crop while tea became the daily drink.
The real difference is culture. Ethiopia is the birthplace of arabica, and coffee is part of daily life. The coffee ceremony (buna), where beans are roasted, ground and brewed in front of guests, is a social ritual in homes across the Ethiopia and this is a major driver of high domestic consumption.
Indonesia: A Big Population
Indonesia keeps more than 40% of its coffee at home, mostly robusta and lower grades. The main driver is population: Indonesians drink only about 1 kg of green coffee per person a year, below the world average of about 1.3 kg, but with around 285m people, that adds up to a huge sum of almost 5m bags.
So, the habit is wide rather than deep. Coffee came with the Dutch in the late 1600s, and today “ngopi” (having coffee) means hanging out with friends at a warung kopi, the small coffee stall found in every neighbourhood. However, most cups are light: 3-in-1 sachets hold only a few grams of coffee, and sweet tea is just as common. It is the size of the population that turns this habit into a big domestic consumption.
[Curious what's driving coffee prices? Explore our Premium Coffee Research with a free trial.]
The split by quality follows the money. About 10m of the 11.38m bags are robusta. The high-quality arabicas from Sumatra, Java and Sulawesi earn premiums abroad, so they are mostly exported, while price-sensitive local drinkers buy cheaper robusta, and nearly a third of what they drink is soluble.
The Recipe: Population, Culture and Structure
Ultimately, high domestic consumption in coffee origins seem to take several ingredients. By examining Brazil, Ethiopia and Indonesia, I think it's safe to conclude that a big population alone is not enough, and neither is culture alone.
It's a rather a combination of:
A large population, so that even a modest habit adds up to millions of bags (e.g.: Indonesia).
A coffee-drinking culture that goes back generations.
A structure that includes local roasting and soluble industries.
There is also a fourth factor, which is income. Coffee consumption per person tends to rise with GDP per capita, as more people can afford it daily. This matters especially for large, lower-income countries, where a small rise in income across a huge population can draw in a lot of coffee.
Ultimately, we can examine the other origins to validate the combination that turns an origin into a big consumer. Take Colombia, for example: it has a coffee-drinking culture, but "only" around 53m people and a premium export model (selling high-priced coffee abroad), so it drinks only about 16% of its crop (not a huge sum), and so it exports most of its coffee.
[Looking for reliable coffee market research? Start a free trial of our Premium Reports today!]
India has more than 1.4 billion people, which is a huge population. However, it's mainly a tea country, and only consumes about a quarter of its own coffee (~1.5m bags), mostly as soluble. Still a meaningful volume, but very modest for a population of that size.
Conclusions
High domestic consumption at origin is less a matter of taste than of scale and history. It takes a population large enough to turn a habit into millions of bags, a coffee culture strong enough to compete with tea, and a market structure to keep local beans at home.
Brazil has all three, Ethiopia relies mostly on culture and Indonesia on sheer size. For the market, these origins are the least transparent part of the balance sheet. Their domestic consumption is hard to measure, yet it takes the first cut of every crop. So, when these origins have a bad harvest, exports absorb part of the shortfall, which tightens supply for destination markets.
[Enjoyed this read? Then you would lover our premium coffee market research. Sign up for a free trial today!]
Comments