top of page

Arabica Certs at Extremely Low Levels

19 minutes ago
3 min read

ICE Arabica certified stocks are in an unusual spot. On Monday (Nov 16), they fell to 186k bags, their lowest level in 27 years. At the same time, Brazilian coffee has started flowing into the exchange: 247k bags are now pending grading, all from Brazil, up 130k bags in a week.


The pending’s are a meaningful step in the right direction, but they are not a game changer. We may get 120–170k bags certified from this volume that’s pending, which is welcomed, as it keeps the situation from getting much worse. However, with certs this low, it would take something closer to 500k–1M bags pending to really start changing the picture.


In this article, we look at the Arabica certs situation, the pending volume and the reasoning behind the Brazilian influx.



Certs Are at 27-Year Lows


Certs have been consumed steadily since the global deficits that started in 2021 (post Brazil frost), and Monday's 186k bags marks the lowest level since 1999.


[What's better than receiving a weekly video report that details what is happening in the coffee market? Nothing. See for yourself here.]


A year ago, certified stocks stood at around 400k bags. Today, they are nearly half of that, and on a longer view, the drop is even more striking: certs peaked above 5 million bags in the early 2000s and were still above 2 million bags as recently as 2021 (before the deficits).


Certs are the coffee that can be delivered against the futures contract, so when that pool is this tight, there is much less coffee available to meet delivery, which may be one factor that’s been lending bullish support to prices.



Since Monday, certs have ticked back up to 201k bags. It’s the first sign that some of the pending coffee is passing grading, but it’s still a very low volume.


Brazil’s Coming in Rapidly


The interesting part is not how much coffee is pending but rather how fast it is arriving. Pending volume has more than doubled in a week, to 247k bags, all from Brazil. That’s up 130k bags week-on-week, with 34k bags added yesterday alone.


For now, 247k bags is no game changer. Pending coffee has arrived at an ICE-licensed warehouse and been submitted for grading, but it isn’t certified yet, and not all of it will pass. Assuming a 50–70% pass rate, 120–170k bags may be admitted as new certs.



Certs keep being consumed at the same time, so the net gain will be smaller. So, even in the best case, based on this volume, certs would still be near multi-decade lows and well below the 400k bags of a year ago. To really start to rebuild certs, we would need something closer to 500k–1M bags pending inspection.


That’s why the fast pace or arrivals is interesting. If it holds, the picture could start to change. Another few weeks of arrivals above 100k bags per week would push pending volumes beyond the 500k-bag range, but the key question is whether this pace can be sustained. I wouldn’t take it for granted.


[Hi there! Like what we have to say? Sign up for a premium subscription and you can be a part of this every week. Get a free trial here!]


Another question worth exploring is why Brazilian coffee is being directed to the exchange now. The answer likely lies in the diffs.


Why Brazil, and Why Now


Brazilian diffs (ICO implied) fell below -5c in Oct. That isn’t an exact break-even level (the “real” break even for semi washed is much lower), but we’ve learned from experience that historically it has been a good signal that certifying Brazilian coffee is starting to make economic sense.



Brazilian exporters can sell coffee in the physical market or deliver it to ICE at a discount to futures. When physical diffs weaken below tenderable parity, ICE becomes the more attractive outlet.


The timing also fits. Brazil shipped record volumes in Oct, and some of that coffee may have been sent to the exchange. Some may have already been sitting in warehouses near the exchange, waiting for certification to make sense.



Either way, the trigger looks the same: diffs fell in October, and the pending’s started climbing in November.


Conclusion


Brazilian diffs are one of the leading indicators to watch for certifications, assuming that the current wave of pending’s followed a crash in Brazil diffs in Oct. A brief dip like that brings in some coffee, enough to slow the decline in certs but it might not be enough to rebuild them.


For the certs picture to really change, I would think diffs need to fall to low levels and stay there for a while. That’s what could bring in the 500k–1M bags of pending coffee needed to meaningfully rebuild certs.


[Feeling like a latte pressure? Let our premium coffee research ease your worries! Sign up for a FREE trial today!]


Comments


bottom of page